If you have been around higher ed for long you have been through the debate about whether we should think about students as customers. The debate (like most on-going topics) usually provides more heat than light.
But I've been thinking about that metaphor as I have spent time in the past few months working with students who have gotten cross-wise with the college (be it because of academic dishonesty, grade disputes, or any of the myriad other ways that students and campuses have a falling out).
In these instances, the student as customer metaphor just doesn't work. It doesn't imply the sort of commitment on the part of either the student or the campus that makes it possible for the parties to work out their difficulties. Other typical metaphors aren't any better. Thinking of students as learners runs aground because most of the disputes are about the failure of students (or their teachers) to achieve learning. For this reason, thinking about students solely as learners ends up in a determination that one party or the other has failed--hardly the sort of outcome that leads to a solution (as opposed to a resolution) of the problem.
So I have turned increasingly to thinking about students as employees. (Perhaps it is a sign that working with the Gore School of Business has influenced my orientation to education. (Not a bad thing at all, in my view.)) On the surface this is a stupid metaphor, since students pay us to go to college, not the other way around. But the student as employee metaphor is an old way to think about education--it is the apprenticeship model of education for an apprentice-less age. And given that at most institutions, student tuition doesn't cover the full costs of educating the student, it isn't far fetched to consider that the institution (or the state's) investment in the student's learning enables us to think that students work for the college and its funders as much as we work for them.
Thinking about a struggling student as an employee forces us to consider what we can do to both raise the quality of his/her work and to fix our own problems. (At least at businesses with a quality employee development program this is exactly how they think about their relationship with employees.) It implies a long-term commitment (interestingly, the median time to graduation and the median time at a certain employer is about the same). And thinking about them as employees requires us to consider where they fit best in an organization, moving them around until we get the best use of their talents and they make the biggest contribution, and ensuring that opportunities for growth are available to all of them.
All of these things--raising the quality of the student's work and the institution's work, making a long-term commitment to their well-being, and finding the right place for them--happen to be hallmarks of good student development practice as well. So perhaps by borrowing a metaphor from the business world we can strengthen the practices of colleges and universities that are already aligned with getting the best out of a student by giving that student our best in return.
Saturday, October 23, 2010
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
A traditionalist case for e-portfolios
Most proponents and opponents of electronic portfolios are future-oriented, focusing on how e-portfolios meld technology, assessment, learning, and employment into an education tool for the coming decades. Their only difference is over whether this coming future is a good one or a bad one.
It strikes me that whenever opponents and proponents agree on the nature of a thing, and differ only on the value of that nature, it is time to question the agreement.
So here goes. In my view, the real power of e-portfolios has not to do with the future but instead with the traditions of higher education, and because I value each of the following traditions, I support the use of portfolios to achieve them.
Here are the traditions, with the ways that e-portfolios make them more vital:
Tradition 1: Education is about more than developing narrow disciplinary or employment skills. Westminster like most institutions has a set of college-wide learning goals, rooted in the traditions of the liberal arts in the US. We desire students to become critical thinkers, to communicate well, the be reflective and creative, to be able to work with others, and to develop a sense of their place in the world. These are old aims, but for the past 50 years or so, they have been out of vogue in higher education, replaced with narrower goals tied to the major and career. E-portfolios (at least in the way Westminster hopes to use them) make the old, pre-disciplinary goals real, because they require students to make connections between their course work and the broadest aspirations of the institution.
Tradition 2: Education is about the formation or development of students into their full humanity. Not only do we hope that students will see beyond narrow boundaries, but we also hope that a college education helps them develop a sense of themselves as human beings, as actors in a complicated but rewarding world. But in much of American higher ed, the focus on the development or formation of students as humans is in decline, replaced again by a career focus. E-portfolios are a tool to remind students of their development, since portfolios track student growth across time, and require students to reflect on that growth as demonstrated in and outside the classroom.
Tradition 3: Student formation should take place in conjunction with mentors who nudge them to be wise in their development. The oldest images of education are of a students linked with a mentor who, having been through the process, can provide guidance to students in their growth. But in most institutions that mentoring, at least for most students, has been replaced by advising--by employees of the college helping students select classes, get internships, and stay on the course to graduation. Nothing wrong with any of these things, but if they constitute the whole of the mentoring relationship, then that relationship hardly does as much as it ought. Because the evaluation of an e-portfolio (at least in our proposed system) should take place in conversation with mentors, e-portfolios can be part of the mentoring that was once at the heart of human formation.
Tradition 4: The previous traditions ought to take place in a democratic setting. One of the great innovations of American higher education has been to link the first three traditions with democratic aspirations--that those things ought to be part of the lives of all people, not just the rich, white, well-off people who tended to have access to them in other settings. But in higher ed today, the first three traditions are part of the experience of a limited group--honors students, students who pick traditional liberal arts majors, those who are savvy enough to tie into the informal system of opportunities that flow to the "best" students. E-portfolios, though, if they are done well, are an expectation of all students. And so they are democratic, making it more possible for all students, not just the privileged, to participate in the broad, formative, mentored learning that is as significant today as when it was created long ago.
So whatever else e-portfolios do for the future, my hope is that they do something important to revive the past, a past that holds out the hope that education is more than a functional, narrow, career-focused traipse through a series of discipline-focused classes.
It strikes me that whenever opponents and proponents agree on the nature of a thing, and differ only on the value of that nature, it is time to question the agreement.
So here goes. In my view, the real power of e-portfolios has not to do with the future but instead with the traditions of higher education, and because I value each of the following traditions, I support the use of portfolios to achieve them.
Here are the traditions, with the ways that e-portfolios make them more vital:
Tradition 1: Education is about more than developing narrow disciplinary or employment skills. Westminster like most institutions has a set of college-wide learning goals, rooted in the traditions of the liberal arts in the US. We desire students to become critical thinkers, to communicate well, the be reflective and creative, to be able to work with others, and to develop a sense of their place in the world. These are old aims, but for the past 50 years or so, they have been out of vogue in higher education, replaced with narrower goals tied to the major and career. E-portfolios (at least in the way Westminster hopes to use them) make the old, pre-disciplinary goals real, because they require students to make connections between their course work and the broadest aspirations of the institution.
Tradition 2: Education is about the formation or development of students into their full humanity. Not only do we hope that students will see beyond narrow boundaries, but we also hope that a college education helps them develop a sense of themselves as human beings, as actors in a complicated but rewarding world. But in much of American higher ed, the focus on the development or formation of students as humans is in decline, replaced again by a career focus. E-portfolios are a tool to remind students of their development, since portfolios track student growth across time, and require students to reflect on that growth as demonstrated in and outside the classroom.
Tradition 3: Student formation should take place in conjunction with mentors who nudge them to be wise in their development. The oldest images of education are of a students linked with a mentor who, having been through the process, can provide guidance to students in their growth. But in most institutions that mentoring, at least for most students, has been replaced by advising--by employees of the college helping students select classes, get internships, and stay on the course to graduation. Nothing wrong with any of these things, but if they constitute the whole of the mentoring relationship, then that relationship hardly does as much as it ought. Because the evaluation of an e-portfolio (at least in our proposed system) should take place in conversation with mentors, e-portfolios can be part of the mentoring that was once at the heart of human formation.
Tradition 4: The previous traditions ought to take place in a democratic setting. One of the great innovations of American higher education has been to link the first three traditions with democratic aspirations--that those things ought to be part of the lives of all people, not just the rich, white, well-off people who tended to have access to them in other settings. But in higher ed today, the first three traditions are part of the experience of a limited group--honors students, students who pick traditional liberal arts majors, those who are savvy enough to tie into the informal system of opportunities that flow to the "best" students. E-portfolios, though, if they are done well, are an expectation of all students. And so they are democratic, making it more possible for all students, not just the privileged, to participate in the broad, formative, mentored learning that is as significant today as when it was created long ago.
So whatever else e-portfolios do for the future, my hope is that they do something important to revive the past, a past that holds out the hope that education is more than a functional, narrow, career-focused traipse through a series of discipline-focused classes.
Tuesday, October 12, 2010
Do college dropouts really cost the nation billions?
The Salt Lake Tribune recently reported under the headline, "College dropouts cost taxpayers billions" that many students who receive federal grants or financial aid in their first years fail to graduate. The article and the study suggest that the money is thus poorly invested.
Really? After all, college graduates also cost taxpayers billions. The truth is that money spent to help students in college is only returned over time in taxes and contributions to community well-being.
The bigger point is this: the education discussion is so fixated on college graduation as preparation for employment that politicians, researchers, and policy wonks overlook this single fact: going to college is about learning. If students learn in their time in college, then they (and the rest of us) benefit, even if they don't graduate. And if they don't learn, graduation gets us nowhere. I am in total agreement that more students need to succeed in college to ensure our future well-being. But I disagree with the related notion, floated in this article and at the core of the recent Obama Administration announcement of support for community colleges, that a college education is foremost about employment. Education is first about learning, and second about becoming. The act of learning and the act of becoming an educated person are prior to employment, not eclipsed by it.
Really? After all, college graduates also cost taxpayers billions. The truth is that money spent to help students in college is only returned over time in taxes and contributions to community well-being.
The bigger point is this: the education discussion is so fixated on college graduation as preparation for employment that politicians, researchers, and policy wonks overlook this single fact: going to college is about learning. If students learn in their time in college, then they (and the rest of us) benefit, even if they don't graduate. And if they don't learn, graduation gets us nowhere. I am in total agreement that more students need to succeed in college to ensure our future well-being. But I disagree with the related notion, floated in this article and at the core of the recent Obama Administration announcement of support for community colleges, that a college education is foremost about employment. Education is first about learning, and second about becoming. The act of learning and the act of becoming an educated person are prior to employment, not eclipsed by it.
Which exceptional students get our attention? Which deserve it? Why?
As Dean I met two types of students--super-achievers who because of their grades, or their interests or their insights have become prominent, and struggling students who because of their grades or their challenges have become prominent. Both groups of students share a characteristic--they become visible to administrators because they are exceptional and seek exceptions.
Colleges are good at working with the first group of students, and not always good at working with the second group. I have been wondering why that is. The answer is probably straight-forward--the first group of students are good at school and so are good at getting the attention of schools. But some of the reason turns on the ability of students to fit into standardized ways of working with them.
Take the curriculum, for example. High achieving students by-and-large flourish within the sort of curricula we offer--academic programs that include lots of pieces and require lots of student-directed choices about electives.
Or take policies on exceptions--high achieving students build connections with faculty who tend to be leaders, and who therefore understand things like exceptions policies, opportunities for withdrawal from academic programs, or ways to discover research or job opportunities. Struggling students don't routinely build connections with faculty (in fact they often say they don't want to bother their professors or ask for special help) and so when it comes time to seek some sort of leg up, they don't always get it. Instead, their interaction with faculty or administrators often comes ex post facto--the opportunity has been missed, the exception not granted, the course failed--and then the student wants to know why.
There are plenty of solutions to this set of problems, but the thing I am most interested in is how the sort of experiences we provide send signals to various types of students. As I suggested above, high achieving students work well in standardized systems--they learn how the systems work, and they learn how the system builds connections that can be then used to deal with exceptions.
Struggling or isolated students don't work well in standardized systems. Instead they work well in systems with two components. The first is perhaps obvious--personalization. Struggling students need individualized attention. Brochures mapping out the curriculum aren't particularly useful; personalized conversations with real human beings are.
The second is less noted--such students flourish in a school that values common experiences. Limit the curricular choices, or ensure that all students participate in learning communities, or require that all students read a particular book, or achieve a set of learning outcomes, and you establish a system that values common experiences. Note that common experiences are different from standard systems. In standard systems the focus is on the well-being of the system--completing or waiving prerequisites for example, or ensuring that students complete a particular number of credit hours. In a common system, all students are expected to have the same experiences.
There is a final point to be made--personalized and common experiences are deeply connected. Require all students to study abroad and they have both a powerful common experience--learning in a foreign setting--and a powerful personal experience--making sense of who they are by learning in a foreign setting. Put them in a standard system, and the range of personal learning decreases, because the point of reference is the requirement, the system, not the experience. And when all students have both powerful common and powerful personal experiences, the struggling student becomes center stage as a person, not just as a seeker of special favors from the administration.
Colleges are good at working with the first group of students, and not always good at working with the second group. I have been wondering why that is. The answer is probably straight-forward--the first group of students are good at school and so are good at getting the attention of schools. But some of the reason turns on the ability of students to fit into standardized ways of working with them.
Take the curriculum, for example. High achieving students by-and-large flourish within the sort of curricula we offer--academic programs that include lots of pieces and require lots of student-directed choices about electives.
Or take policies on exceptions--high achieving students build connections with faculty who tend to be leaders, and who therefore understand things like exceptions policies, opportunities for withdrawal from academic programs, or ways to discover research or job opportunities. Struggling students don't routinely build connections with faculty (in fact they often say they don't want to bother their professors or ask for special help) and so when it comes time to seek some sort of leg up, they don't always get it. Instead, their interaction with faculty or administrators often comes ex post facto--the opportunity has been missed, the exception not granted, the course failed--and then the student wants to know why.
There are plenty of solutions to this set of problems, but the thing I am most interested in is how the sort of experiences we provide send signals to various types of students. As I suggested above, high achieving students work well in standardized systems--they learn how the systems work, and they learn how the system builds connections that can be then used to deal with exceptions.
Struggling or isolated students don't work well in standardized systems. Instead they work well in systems with two components. The first is perhaps obvious--personalization. Struggling students need individualized attention. Brochures mapping out the curriculum aren't particularly useful; personalized conversations with real human beings are.
The second is less noted--such students flourish in a school that values common experiences. Limit the curricular choices, or ensure that all students participate in learning communities, or require that all students read a particular book, or achieve a set of learning outcomes, and you establish a system that values common experiences. Note that common experiences are different from standard systems. In standard systems the focus is on the well-being of the system--completing or waiving prerequisites for example, or ensuring that students complete a particular number of credit hours. In a common system, all students are expected to have the same experiences.
There is a final point to be made--personalized and common experiences are deeply connected. Require all students to study abroad and they have both a powerful common experience--learning in a foreign setting--and a powerful personal experience--making sense of who they are by learning in a foreign setting. Put them in a standard system, and the range of personal learning decreases, because the point of reference is the requirement, the system, not the experience. And when all students have both powerful common and powerful personal experiences, the struggling student becomes center stage as a person, not just as a seeker of special favors from the administration.
Labels:
student engagement
Friday, October 1, 2010
Reflections on interim leadership and willingness
Since the beginning of June I have served as the Interim Dean of the Bill and Vieve Gore School of Business. Doing so has given me plenty of opportunities to think about (and experience) interim leadership.
Interim leadership raises all sorts of questions--about knowledge (how much do you have to know about something to provide leadership there?), change (is an interim period of leadership a good time to bring about change or a bad time?), and the value of an outside perspective (when is an outside perspective good? what is it good at?).
But for me the most interesting question, and one that I understand only in limited ways, is "where does the authority of an interim leader come from"? This is a real question in politics, where a "lame duck" President or Congress is considered weak and ineffective at best, and prone to self-dealing at worst. And it is a real question in business and higher ed as well, where the tenure of most leaders is brief enough that they can be considered "interim" whether or not their title includes it.
Non-interim leaders seem to get authority in several ways. Their position gives them authority because of their location in the organization and the official power that comes from it. Their permanence gives them power because their colleagues all know that in most instances they will have to deal with the leader again in the future. And their experience brings them power, as they amass knowledge, connections, and stories that allow experience to buttress their institutional influence.
An interim leader has none of these options--their position is by definition brief and limited ("interim" means "meanwhile" or "in-between" in Latin, a perfect description of the location of the interim leader), they have neither permanence nor experience. Instead, it seems that an interim leader's authority depends overwhelmingly on the willingness of other members of the organization to create it.
I fell this everyday in my role, where my colleagues, for many reasons, are willing (in the active sense of the word "willing") to have me in the interim dean position. I am deeply grateful to them for this willingness, both because it makes my work much better, and because I think it is a key component of healthy organizations. Flourishing organizations rely on the impetus of their members to move. When those members willfully work with an interim leader they are granting their energy to the organization, trusting that their efforts will extend beyond the interim leader's term of service. Not a bad thing at all.
Interim leadership raises all sorts of questions--about knowledge (how much do you have to know about something to provide leadership there?), change (is an interim period of leadership a good time to bring about change or a bad time?), and the value of an outside perspective (when is an outside perspective good? what is it good at?).
But for me the most interesting question, and one that I understand only in limited ways, is "where does the authority of an interim leader come from"? This is a real question in politics, where a "lame duck" President or Congress is considered weak and ineffective at best, and prone to self-dealing at worst. And it is a real question in business and higher ed as well, where the tenure of most leaders is brief enough that they can be considered "interim" whether or not their title includes it.
Non-interim leaders seem to get authority in several ways. Their position gives them authority because of their location in the organization and the official power that comes from it. Their permanence gives them power because their colleagues all know that in most instances they will have to deal with the leader again in the future. And their experience brings them power, as they amass knowledge, connections, and stories that allow experience to buttress their institutional influence.
An interim leader has none of these options--their position is by definition brief and limited ("interim" means "meanwhile" or "in-between" in Latin, a perfect description of the location of the interim leader), they have neither permanence nor experience. Instead, it seems that an interim leader's authority depends overwhelmingly on the willingness of other members of the organization to create it.
I fell this everyday in my role, where my colleagues, for many reasons, are willing (in the active sense of the word "willing") to have me in the interim dean position. I am deeply grateful to them for this willingness, both because it makes my work much better, and because I think it is a key component of healthy organizations. Flourishing organizations rely on the impetus of their members to move. When those members willfully work with an interim leader they are granting their energy to the organization, trusting that their efforts will extend beyond the interim leader's term of service. Not a bad thing at all.
Labels:
leadership
Thursday, September 23, 2010
Obama and the Tea Party
A large group of citizens, not traditionally engaged in political life but angry at a sitting President who does not face re-election, form a grassroots movement. As they gain power a young, relatively inexperienced politician becomes their spokesperson. The movement raises a ton of money, and consistently defeats establishment candidates from the party they are most closely aligned with. The movement has ill-defined policies, but is generally seen as more extreme than the party's traditional constituencies. By the time the party realizes it, the movement has eclipsed it, so all the party can do is come along for the ride, preferring some victory at the polls to defending its more traditional policies and actions.
The paragraph above describes the Tea Party and Sarah Palin. But it also describes Barack Obama and the movement that carried him to power. I do not mean to suggest equivalency between Obama and Palin. Nor do I believe that this is a case of history repeating itself. But it is part of a broad trend in civic life, where it is easier than ever to engage and connect with like-minded people to bring about short-term change. The case of Obama suggests that this sort of change may not be durable, but nonetheless we ought to realized that the Tea Party and the Obama revolution are part of the same thread in American life.
The paragraph above describes the Tea Party and Sarah Palin. But it also describes Barack Obama and the movement that carried him to power. I do not mean to suggest equivalency between Obama and Palin. Nor do I believe that this is a case of history repeating itself. But it is part of a broad trend in civic life, where it is easier than ever to engage and connect with like-minded people to bring about short-term change. The case of Obama suggests that this sort of change may not be durable, but nonetheless we ought to realized that the Tea Party and the Obama revolution are part of the same thread in American life.
Labels:
civic engagement,
local change
Monday, September 20, 2010
The fortune at the bottom of the higher education pyramid
Daniel Griswold, Director of the Center for Trade Policy Studies at the Cato Institute, spoke at Westminster last week about his new book, Mad About Trade. The talk was part of our Weldon J. Taylor Executive Lecture Series, and it was pitched perfectly for the audience--a mixture of students, faculty, and community members interested in global issues and connected to the Utah Council for Citizen Diplomacy, our partner in the lecture series.
Most of Griswold's talk focused on the benefits of global trade, but he made a passing comment that has had me thinking ever since. He noted that while the cost of many things produced in a global system has declined rapidly (think TVs, computers, etc.), the cost of things impervious to global trade has risen rapidly. And of course the two industries that make this case are health care and higher education.
The general recipe for driving down the cost of things in global trade is the reduction of trade barriers. And there are certainly barriers to trade in higher education, most particularly the quotas and visa system that make it difficult for international students to study in the US (and vice versa) because they cannot get access to higher ed here.
But it is my sense that the main barrier is the unwillingness of American higher education to look at the right markets. Where American colleges and universities do make international partnerships, they tend to target the upper third of the pyramid--those people who have already become part of the global middle class and can therefore afford something like a full-ticket American education.
You can see this approach both in the partnerships that US universities make globally--the NYU campus in Abu Dhabi, for example; or Yale's foray into creating a liberal arts college in Singapore--and in the international students that US campuses recruit.
In doing this American higher ed overlooks the huge changes in the developing world. There are dozens, but four that stand out are these:
Such schools would both help colleges and universities live out their commitment to helping people and their communities build better lives, and help colleges and universities figure out how to do their work less expensively, while maintaining the quality that we are justly renowned for.
Most of Griswold's talk focused on the benefits of global trade, but he made a passing comment that has had me thinking ever since. He noted that while the cost of many things produced in a global system has declined rapidly (think TVs, computers, etc.), the cost of things impervious to global trade has risen rapidly. And of course the two industries that make this case are health care and higher education.
The general recipe for driving down the cost of things in global trade is the reduction of trade barriers. And there are certainly barriers to trade in higher education, most particularly the quotas and visa system that make it difficult for international students to study in the US (and vice versa) because they cannot get access to higher ed here.
But it is my sense that the main barrier is the unwillingness of American higher education to look at the right markets. Where American colleges and universities do make international partnerships, they tend to target the upper third of the pyramid--those people who have already become part of the global middle class and can therefore afford something like a full-ticket American education.
You can see this approach both in the partnerships that US universities make globally--the NYU campus in Abu Dhabi, for example; or Yale's foray into creating a liberal arts college in Singapore--and in the international students that US campuses recruit.
In doing this American higher ed overlooks the huge changes in the developing world. There are dozens, but four that stand out are these:
- the pace of urbanization is picking up in the developing world, and with it the amassing of millions of people in close proximity to each other,
- the cities of the developing world are showing signs of increased vitality and creativity, most particularly in those sections settled by squatters,
- squatter cities have shown themselves to be tremendous economic engines--that is there are fortunes at the bottom of the pyramid-- and to be much greener than older cities, small towns, or suburbs--that is, a sustainable future depends on the ability of humans to live successfully in cities (see Stewart Brand's Whole Earth Discipline: An Eco-pragmatist Manifesto for a clear account of the vitality of squatter cities),
- and one engine of economic improvement and social well-being are schools in those cities, organized and paid for by parents.
Such schools would both help colleges and universities live out their commitment to helping people and their communities build better lives, and help colleges and universities figure out how to do their work less expensively, while maintaining the quality that we are justly renowned for.
Labels:
civic engagement,
cost,
quality,
questioning assumptions
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)